
I want to tell you the long, true story of my life with toads.
This spring and summer I have developed an intense and complex relationship to
Bufo americanus -- the American Toad. We have many of them. And they live all over our acre of open grass. So, when I mow, I am inevitably almost-mowing toads all of the time. I have evidence that I have mowed at least one toad -- I found a toad limb in the mower's bagger after I was done mowing. Given that I was the Girl Scout who staged a teary intervention when my sister-scouts took to squashing daddy long-legs, I have developed a deep concern for the fate of the toad.
My solution has been to stage what I call the Toad Relocation Project. The site for their relocation has been the garden, where I imagined the toads would be safe from the blades of our lawn devices while enjoying leisurely life among the plants. I was encouraged by Dan who kept saying, in his slight New England brogue, "ah, yes, toads are GOOD for the garden." Imagine my delight when we discovered that this was not just a generalized good (like good karma) but that they actually eat the pests we were trying to rid ourselves of.
I diligently watch for toads while mowing, and even make a pre-mow walk-through to secure the lawn. I have carried at least thirty toads into the garden in the past months, picking them up carefully, stroking their little rugged backs, talking to them as I walk them to the garden.
You are going to a better place, Mr. Toad. You will be very happy in Gardenland.
Before I go further, I should say that the similarities of my behavior and that of, say, Roosevelt issuing internment orders for Japanese Americans, is not lost on me. I have spent a lot of time this summer thinking about the management of populations. Whether it is while I am collecting and drowning cucumber beetles, moving toads from one place to another, or removing "invasive species" plants from our woods, I am disturbed by the human desire to choreograph the life and death of species. There is no place where this is more evident than in my relationship to toads. As I carry them across the expansive lawn, remove them from their families and homes, promising them that I know what is best for their well-being, I am deeply troubled by the underlying meaning of it all. And yet, I keep telling myself,
toads are not humans, and I am not Hitler. And this nagging worry about the implications of my Toad Relocation Project came to a head on Saturday. I was working on securing the outside perimeter of our garden, and re-attaching the fine, mesh netting we used to create our fence. As I bent down to the ground to tuck the fabric close to the post, I noticed a little reptilian-esque face staring up at me. I began to scream one of those short, loud screams that means utter panic and freaked-out-ness. I looked again at what I thought was a snake preparing to pounce, only to realize that what I was looking at was a very dead, shriveled, but fully preserved toad carcass. The toad, in an attempt to escape Gardenland, had become stuck in the netting and could not get out. This toad was big and fat (his shrunken carcass was still bigger than most of our other toads); one can only assume that this guy couldn't get through and died from starvation and dehydration in the hot summer sun.
There is not enough room here to explain the deep psychological disturbance caused by my finding of the toad. I felt guilty and sad and really sick to my stomach. It helped that I was not alone in the garden. After I cut the poor dead soul out of the fence, Andrew came over and, in true 13-year-old-boyness said "Wow. Cool!" Dan echoed Andrew's response, while Rhonda, perceiving my distress, looked me in the face and said, "Amy. Toads die." Andrew promptly named the critter Norbert, and suggested that we keep him in a box and show him to all our friends. Buddy seemed to think he might want to eat Norbert, but I decided to photograph him. One might think it perverse that sensitive-girl then turns to photographing her sad, dead, toad, but I like to think of it as some kind of healing. Coming to terms with the fact that toads do die, and this one died in a pretty spectacular way. And, it was just one toad. As I watered the garden in the early morning, I saw many toads hopping between boxes and sitting under plants. Many toads are still in the garden while others (those skinnier than Norbert) have successfully escaped.
Norbert now lives in our sun room where he enjoys life among houseplants and a view of the big bad world.